Converting to Propane: Can I Use Propane on a Natural Gas Water Heater?"

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

The choice of energy source for your water heater is a critical decision that can significantly impact your daily comfort and utility bills. Many homeowners rely on natural gas as a primary energy source due to its affordability and availability in most regions. However, circumstances may arise where you might consider using propane as an alternative fuel for your natural gas water heater. Whether you’re facing a shortage of natural gas supply, moving to an area with limited access to natural gas, or exploring more environmentally friendly options, understanding the feasibility and safety of using propane on a natural gas water heater is essential. In this guide, we’ll delve into the factors, considerations, and safety precautions involved in using propane as an alternative fuel source for your existing natural gas water heater, helping you make an informed decision about your home’s hot water supply.

Page Content

Understanding Natural Gas Water Heaters

Natural gas water heaters are common household appliances used to provide hot water for various domestic needs. They are efficient and reliable, making them a popular choice for homeowners. To fully understand how these water heaters work, it’s essential to delve into their components, operation, and efficiency ratings.

Overview of Natural Gas Water Heaters

Natural gas water heaters are appliances designed to heat and store or provide on-demand hot water for residential and commercial use. They are favored for their cost-effectiveness and ability to deliver a continuous supply of hot water.

Common Household Use

Provide hot water for bathing, washing dishes, and doing laundry.
Used in kitchens, bathrooms, and utility rooms.

Energy Source: Natural Gas

Natural gas is a common energy source for water heaters due to its affordability and availability in many regions.

Types of Natural Gas Water Heaters

Natural gas water heaters come in two main types, each with its advantages and disadvantages:

1. Tankless (On-Demand) Water Heaters

Heats water only when needed.
No storage tank, which saves space.
Offers continuous hot water supply.
Energy-efficient as it avoids standby heat loss.

2. Storage Tank Water Heaters

Stores and heats a specific volume of water in a tank.
Provides hot water even during high-demand periods.
May have varying tank sizes to meet different household needs.
Generally cost-effective to install.

Key Components

Understanding the essential components of a natural gas water heater is crucial to grasp how it functions:

Burner

Combusts natural gas to heat water.
Located at the bottom of the tank or within the heating unit (for tankless models).

Thermostat

Monitors and controls the water temperature.
Allows users to set their desired hot water temperature.

Gas Valve

Regulates the flow of natural gas to the burner.
Ensures safety by controlling gas supply.

Flue Pipe

Exhausts combustion byproducts, such as carbon monoxide, safely outdoors.

Tank (For Storage Heaters)

Stores and maintains hot water until it’s needed.
Typically insulated to reduce heat loss.

Efficiency Ratings

Understanding the efficiency ratings of natural gas water heaters helps consumers choose the most cost-effective and environmentally friendly options:

Energy Factor (EF)

Measures the overall energy efficiency of the water heater.
Takes into account factors like standby heat loss and recovery efficiency.
Higher EF ratings indicate greater efficiency.

Uniform Energy Factor (UEF)

A standardized rating system introduced in 2015.
Provides a more accurate measure of efficiency, particularly for tankless models.
Allows for better comparison between different types and brands of water heaters.

This comprehensive overview of natural gas water heaters should give you a clear understanding of how these appliances function and their various components and efficiency ratings.

Propane as an Alternative Fuel

Propane is a versatile and clean-burning alternative fuel that has gained popularity for various applications, including residential heating, cooking, and powering vehicles. Understanding the properties and benefits of propane can help individuals and businesses make informed decisions about its use.

What Is Propane?

Propane, also known as liquefied petroleum gas (LPG), is a hydrocarbon gas that exists in a liquefied state under moderate pressure or at reduced temperatures. It is a byproduct of natural gas processing and crude oil refining.

Characteristics of Propane

Odorless and Colorless

Pure propane is odorless and colorless. An odorant called ethyl mercaptan is added for leak detection, giving it a distinct smell.

High Energy Density

Propane has a high energy content per unit volume, making it an efficient fuel source.

Clean-Burning

Propane combustion produces fewer emissions and greenhouse gases compared to other fossil fuels.

Non-Toxic

Propane is not harmful to health when handled correctly.

Versatility

It can be used for various applications, including heating, cooking, hot water, and as a transportation fuel.

Reasons for Considering Propane

Reduced Emissions

Propane burns cleaner than gasoline or diesel, emitting fewer pollutants and particulate matter.

Lower Carbon Footprint

Propane has a lower carbon content, contributing less to global warming.

Cost Efficiency

Competitive Pricing

Propane is often more affordable than gasoline and diesel, making it an attractive option for budget-conscious consumers.

Energy Efficiency

Propane-powered appliances tend to be energy-efficient, reducing overall energy costs.

Energy Security

Domestic Production

A significant portion of propane used in the United States is domestically produced, reducing dependence on foreign oil.

2.Storage and Availability

Propane is easily stored and transported, ensuring a reliable supply even in remote areas.

Key Differences Between Propane and Natural Gas

Understanding the distinctions between propane and natural gas is essential when considering the use of propane as an alternative fuel.

Energy Content

Propane contains more energy per unit volume than natural gas, resulting in higher combustion efficiency.

Storage

Propane is stored in tanks as a liquid, while natural gas is delivered via pipelines.

Combustion Properties

Propane burns hotter and is often preferred for high-heat applications like cooking and space heating.

Portability

Propane tanks are portable, making it suitable for off-grid applications, including grilling and camping.

Transportation

Propane can power vehicles through propane autogas, offering a greener alternative to gasoline or diesel.

Safety Considerations

Handling and Storage

Proper storage and handling procedures are essential to prevent leaks, fires, or explosions.

Ventilation

Adequate ventilation is crucial when using propane indoors to prevent the buildup of potentially dangerous gases.

Professional Installation

Installation and maintenance of propane-powered appliances should be performed by certified professionals.

This comprehensive overview of propane as an alternative fuel provides valuable information about its characteristics, benefits, and key differences from natural gas. It also emphasizes the importance of safety when using propane for various applications.

Can You Use Propane on a Natural Gas Water Heater?

Natural gas water heaters are designed to operate on a specific type of fuel—natural gas. However, in some cases, homeowners may consider using propane as an alternative fuel source due to availability or other reasons. Converting a natural gas water heater to run on propane is possible but involves several important considerations and safety precautions:

Compatibility:

Determine if your natural gas water heater is designed for dual-fuel use or conversion to propane. Not all water heaters can be converted, so it’s crucial to check the manufacturer’s specifications and guidelines.

Burner Type and Orifice Size:

Natural gas and propane have different combustion characteristics. The burner and orifice size may need to be changed to ensure proper combustion and efficiency when switching from natural gas to propane. Consult the manufacturer’s recommendations for the specific adjustments required.

Venting and Safety:

Propane and natural gas produce different combustion byproducts, and their venting requirements can vary. Ensure that the venting system is compatible with propane and complies with safety standards to prevent the buildup of potentially dangerous gases.

Manufacturer Guidelines:

Always refer to the manufacturer’s guidelines and warranty information. Modifying your water heater without following their instructions can void warranties and may pose safety risks.

Professional Assistance:

Converting a water heater from natural gas to propane should ideally be performed by a qualified technician or plumber experienced in propane conversions. They can assess your specific water heater, make the necessary adjustments, and ensure the installation complies with local codes and safety regulations.

Gas Supply Line:

Ensure that your gas supply line is equipped for propane. Propane typically requires a different regulator and gas line than natural gas. These components must be compatible with propane’s higher pressure.

Leak Testing:

After conversion, thorough leak testing should be conducted to ensure there are no gas leaks, as propane is heavier than air and can collect in low-lying areas.

Local Regulations:

Be aware of local regulations and codes related to gas conversions. Some areas may have specific requirements for gas appliance conversions that must be followed.

Safety Precautions:

Safety should always be a top priority. Follow all safety guidelines, use proper equipment, and be vigilant in checking for gas leaks during and after the conversion.

In summary, while it is possible to convert a natural gas water heater to use propane, it should be done carefully and in compliance with manufacturer recommendations and local regulations. Seeking professional assistance for the conversion is advisable to ensure safety, efficiency, and compliance with all relevant standards. Failure to follow proper procedures can result in safety hazards and damage to the appliance.

Converting a Natural Gas Water Heater to Propane

Converting a natural gas water heater to operate on propane involves several steps and considerations to ensure a safe and effective transition. Before attempting the conversion, it’s crucial to consult the manufacturer’s guidelines and consider professional assistance, as not all water heaters are designed for dual-fuel use. Here are the key details for converting a natural gas water heater to propane:

Check Compatibility:

Verify if your natural gas water heater is convertible to propane. Not all models can be converted, and attempting to convert an incompatible unit can be dangerous and void warranties.

Obtain a Conversion Kit:

Contact the manufacturer or an authorized dealer to purchase a propane conversion kit designed for your specific water heater model. These kits typically include the necessary components for the conversion, such as a new burner and gas valve.

Shut Off Gas Supply:

Before starting any work, ensure the gas supply to the water heater is turned off. Locate the gas shut-off valve and make sure it’s in the “off” position.

Drain the Tank:

Empty the water heater tank completely. You can do this by turning off the cold water supply to the tank and opening a hot water faucet in your home.

Remove the Burner Assembly:

Carefully disassemble the burner assembly according to the manufacturer’s instructions. This typically involves removing the burner, gas valve, and related components.

Install the Propane Burner and Components:

Follow the conversion kit instructions to install the new propane burner, gas valve, and any other components provided in the kit. Ensure that all connections are secure and leak-free.

Adjust the Orifice Size:

The orifice size on the new propane burner must match the propane gas supply. The conversion kit should include the appropriate orifice, which may need to be installed or adjusted to the correct size.

Venting Considerations:

Check if any modifications are needed to the venting system to accommodate propane combustion byproducts. Consult local building codes and safety standards for guidance.

Gas Supply Line:

Make sure the gas supply line is equipped for propane. Propane typically requires a different regulator and gas line than natural gas. These components must be compatible with propane’s higher pressure.

Converting a natural gas water heater to propane should be approached with caution and meticulous attention to detail. When done correctly, it allows you to use propane as an alternative fuel source, but safety and compliance with guidelines should always be the top priorities.

Hiring a Professional vs. DIY Conversion

Deciding whether to hire a professional or attempt a do-it-yourself (DIY) conversion for your natural gas water heater to propane is an important choice that should be based on various factors. Here’s a detailed comparison of hiring a professional versus DIY conversion:

Hiring a Professional:

Pros:

Expertise and Experience: Professional technicians or plumbers have the knowledge and experience to safely and correctly perform the conversion. They are familiar with the intricacies of gas appliances and understand the specific requirements of propane conversions.
Compliance: Professionals are well-versed in local building codes and safety regulations. They ensure that the conversion meets all legal requirements and safety standards, reducing the risk of accidents or non-compliance issues.
Warranty Preservation: Many water heater manufacturers require professional installation or conversion to maintain the warranty. Hiring a professional ensures that your warranty remains intact.
Safety: Safety is a top priority when dealing with gas appliances. Professionals have the necessary tools and equipment to perform leak tests and ensure that the system is safe and leak-free.
Time and Convenience: Hiring a professional can save you time and effort. They typically complete the conversion more quickly and efficiently than a DIY project, allowing you to enjoy the benefits of propane sooner.

Cons:

Cost: Professional services come at a cost, which can vary depending on the complexity of the conversion and your location. While it may be more expensive upfront, it often ensures a safe and compliant conversion.
Dependency: You rely on the availability and schedule of the professional, which may not align with your immediate needs.

DIY Conversion:

Pros:

Cost Savings: DIY conversion can save you money compared to hiring a professional, as you won’t incur labor costs.
Learning Experience: If you have a good understanding of gas systems and are mechanically inclined, a DIY conversion can be a valuable learning experience.
Control: You have full control over the conversion process and can work at your own pace.

Cons:

Safety Risks: Gas conversions involve potential safety hazards, such as gas leaks or improper installations. If not done correctly, it can lead to dangerous situations, fires, or explosions.
Voided Warranty: Many manufacturers require professional installation or conversions to maintain warranties. DIY conversions may void your warranty.
Legal Compliance: Failure to comply with local building codes and safety regulations can result in legal consequences.
Complexity: Converting a gas appliance to a different fuel source is a complex task that requires specialized knowledge and tools. Mistakes can be costly to fix.
Time and Effort: DIY conversions can be time-consuming and may require extensive research and troubleshooting, which can be frustrating and inconvenient.

In summary, the decision to hire a professional or attempt a DIY conversion depends on your level of expertise, comfort with gas systems, budget, and the importance of safety and compliance. If you have any doubts about your ability to safely and correctly perform the conversion, it’s generally recommended to hire a professional to ensure a safe and reliable transition to propane.

Safety Precautions

Safety precautions are of paramount importance when converting a natural gas water heater to propane or making any modifications to gas appliances. Mishandling gas can result in serious hazards, including gas leaks, fires, or explosions. Here are essential safety precautions to follow during a gas water heater conversion:

Shut Off Gas Supply:
- Before starting any work, ensure the gas supply to the water heater is turned off. Locate the gas shut-off valve and make sure it’s in the “off” position.
Ventilation:
- Ensure that the area where you’re working is well-ventilated. Adequate ventilation is crucial to prevent the buildup of potentially harmful gases, including propane.
Gas Leak Detection:
- Use a gas leak detection solution (soapy water or a commercial gas leak detector) to check all connections and joints for leaks. Even a small gas leak can be dangerous.
No Open Flames or Sparks:
- Keep all open flames, sparks, and ignition sources far away from the work area. This includes cigarettes, matches, lighters, and electrical devices that can produce sparks.
Use Proper Tools:
- Use the appropriate tools for the job and ensure they are in good condition. Avoid using makeshift or damaged tools.
Wear Protective Gear:
- Wear appropriate safety gear, including gloves and safety goggles, to protect yourself during the conversion process.
Read Manufacturer Instructions:
- Familiarize yourself with the manufacturer’s guidelines and instructions provided in the conversion kit. Follow them meticulously to ensure a safe and compliant conversion.
Professional Assistance:
- If you’re uncertain about any aspect of the conversion, consider seeking professional assistance. A qualified technician or plumber can ensure a safe and reliable conversion.
Avoid Over-Tightening:
- When making connections, avoid over-tightening fittings and components, as this can damage them and lead to leaks.
Proper Venting:
- Ensure that the venting system is correctly installed and aligned with propane combustion requirements. Consult local building codes for venting standards.
Check for Obstructions:
- Inspect the venting system for any obstructions or blockages that could impede the safe exhaust of combustion byproducts.
Leak Testing:
- After completing the conversion, conduct a thorough leak test using a gas leak detection solution to ensure there are no gas leaks at any connections.
Emergency Plan:
- Have an emergency plan in place in case of a gas leak or other hazardous situation. This plan should include knowing how to shut off the gas supply to your entire home and having emergency contact information readily available.
Testing and Inspection:
- Once the conversion is complete, test the water heater to ensure it operates safely and efficiently. Regularly inspect the appliance for signs of leaks or malfunctions.
Local Regulations:
- Be aware of and comply with local building codes, regulations, and safety standards related to gas appliance conversions. Non-compliance can result in legal consequences.
Carbon Monoxide Detector:
- Install a carbon monoxide (CO) detector near the water heater and in sleeping areas. CO is a colorless, odorless gas produced by incomplete combustion and can be deadly.
Propane Detector:
- Consider installing a propane gas detector near the water heater to provide an additional layer of safety and early warning in case of propane leaks.

Always prioritize safety when working with gas appliances. If you’re unsure about any aspect of the conversion process or lack experience in gas-related tasks, it’s highly advisable to seek the assistance of a qualified professional to ensure a safe and compliant conversion.

Propane vs. Natural Gas Water Heater Cost Comparison

When choosing between a propane and natural gas water heater, cost considerations play a significant role in the decision-making process. Both fuel sources have their advantages and disadvantages in terms of initial costs, operating expenses, and long-term investments.

Initial Costs:

A. Propane Water Heater:

Higher Equipment Cost: Propane water heaters typically have a higher upfront purchase cost compared to natural gas units. This is due to the specialized components required for propane combustion.
Conversion Costs: If you are converting a natural gas water heater to propane, you will need to invest in a conversion kit, which can add to the initial expense.

B. Natural Gas Water Heater:

Lower Equipment Cost: Natural gas water heaters generally have a lower initial purchase price, making them more budget-friendly for many homeowners.
No Conversion Costs: If you already have a natural gas water heater, there are no conversion costs associated with switching to natural gas.

Operating Costs:

A. Propane Water Heater:

Fuel Costs: Propane often costs more per unit of energy (typically measured in BTUs or therms) compared to natural gas. Therefore, you may pay higher monthly fuel bills.
Energy Efficiency: Propane water heaters are known for their energy efficiency, which can help mitigate higher fuel costs to some extent.

B. Natural Gas Water Heater:

Lower Fuel Costs: Natural gas is generally less expensive per unit of energy compared to propane. This results in lower monthly energy bills for natural gas water heaters.
Energy Efficiency: Modern natural gas water heaters are also designed to be energy-efficient, providing cost savings over less efficient models.

Long-Term Cost Considerations:

A. Propane Water Heater:

Fuel Price Volatility: Propane prices can be more volatile and subject to market fluctuations. This can make long-term budgeting less predictable.
Tank Size and Usage: Your propane consumption will depend on factors such as the size of your propane tank and how frequently you use hot water.

B. Natural Gas Water Heater:

Stable Fuel Prices: Natural gas prices tend to be more stable and less susceptible to drastic price increases compared to propane.
Availability: Natural gas is readily available in many urban and suburban areas, reducing supply-related costs.

Additional Factors:

A. Location:

Availability: The availability of natural gas or propane in your area can significantly impact costs. Natural gas may not be accessible in rural or remote regions, making propane a more practical choice.

B. Efficiency Ratings:

Energy Factor (EF) and Uniform Energy Factor (UEF): Compare the EF or UEF ratings of different water heater models to assess their energy efficiency and potential cost savings over time.

C. Rebates and Incentives:

Local Rebates: Check for any local utility rebates or incentives for energy-efficient water heaters, as they can help offset initial costs.

In conclusion, while propane water heaters may have a higher upfront cost and slightly higher fuel prices, they can still provide cost-effective hot water solutions, particularly in areas where natural gas is unavailable. The choice between propane and natural gas water heaters should consider not only upfront expenses but also long-term operating costs and the specific circumstances of your location and usage patterns.

Final word

When deciding whether to use propane or natural gas for your water heater, it’s essential to weigh various factors, including initial costs, operating expenses, and long-term considerations. Here’s a summary of the key points to consider:

Initial Costs:
- Propane water heaters generally have higher upfront purchase costs due to specialized components.
- Natural gas water heaters are often more budget-friendly in terms of initial equipment costs.
Operating Costs:
- Propane typically costs more per unit of energy (BTUs or therms) than natural gas.
- Propane water heaters are known for their energy efficiency, which helps mitigate higher fuel costs.
- Natural gas is less expensive per unit of energy, resulting in lower monthly energy bills.
- Modern natural gas water heaters are designed to be energy-efficient.
Long-Term Cost Considerations:
- Propane prices can be more volatile, making long-term budgeting less predictable.
- Natural gas prices are generally more stable and less susceptible to drastic increases.
- The availability of natural gas or propane in your area can impact costs.
Additional Factors:
- Consider factors such as the efficiency ratings (EF or UEF) of water heater models and the availability of rebates or incentives.

Ultimately, the choice between propane and natural gas for your water heater depends on your location, usage patterns, and budget. It’s crucial to evaluate the complete cost picture, including both initial expenses and long-term operating costs, to make an informed decision. Additionally, safety should always be a top priority when working with gas appliances, whether you’re converting a water heater or using it in your home. If you have any doubts or lack the necessary expertise, seeking professional assistance is advisable to ensure a safe and efficient transition to your chosen fuel source.

Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon.com, Inc, or its affiliates.